Migrant Farmworkers In the United States Analysis

Document Type:Report

Subject Area:Analysis

Document 1

The use of structural violence together with symbolic violence helps Holmes in revealing how some issues such as social hierarchies and inequalities have different categories. He presents that they do not only fall into the sexuality, race, gender, and social categories but what also matters is how they come to be legitimated and internalized (Seth 153). Holmes continues to forcefully argue that it is because of this violence that makes the suffering of migrant works to be taken for granted, neutralized and normalized. It is notable that the migrant workers are exposed to a lot of suffering, and no one gives a second thought to what they are going through. The use of structural violence and symbolic violence through the text indicates how both are related primarily to the social hierarchies and inequalities that look upon the migrant workers.

Sign up to view the full document!

These people require being taken care of just like any other person and the structural violence, and symbolic violence should not be the case here as these migrant workers are also part of the society. To propose an action to address the violence, Holmes calls for reforms that should be directed on the economy, immigration, and the various labor policy. Other areas that require reforms include the social structural analysis especially in the training of public and medical health professionals. The training should help them see past just the behavioral and biological determinants of sicknesses. They should see that they work towards a health care system that is universal. The ethnic-labor hierarchy’s places the United States citizens including the Asian Americans at the top while the undocumented Mexicans are left at the bottom.

Sign up to view the full document!

The migrant farmworkers are invisible because they are not given much recognition by the US citizens besides they are racially segregated. They are also viewed to be coming from a low class, and since they not citizens, they are looked down upon. Critically discuss how Holmes conducted his ethnographic fieldwork. Identify two of the innovative methods that he used. Some of the essential outcomes from Holmes's ethnographic fieldwork study was that many things in the farm were ethnically structured. Some of the structured ethnic issues in the farms were on income, residence pattern on the farm, and difficulty of work. The Mexican Triquis were given some of the works that required intensive labor such as picking of strawberries. This job required the migrant farmworkers to bend in the farms for long periods of their working time.

Sign up to view the full document!

A lot of bending while picking strawberries made most of the workers to have back problems. From the readings, I have learned what most farmworkers face while they are offering labor especially the immigrant farms (Seth 167). I have learned that the migrants face a lot of challenges, they work in poor conditions and their health issues does not matter to the employees. All that the employees care about is that the workers have done their work. Most of the farmworkers are paid low wages, yet they are working some of the labor-intensive jobs that require good pay. Racial discrimination is also another part that I have come to my understanding that these people face.

Sign up to view the full document!

From $10 to earn access

Only on Studyloop

Original template